If you are looking for Glamour, Gadgets and Grissom you won't find them here. Forget what you think you know about 'Forensics', these are the tales of one man and his brush. Of course these views do not represent the views of any Police Force or indeed reflect any Force Policies ya da ya.

Sunday 13 May 2007

Whoooooo are you oh oh oh, we know but you've been NFA'd

Ok, no spanking new CSI blog would be complete without the inevitable comparisons of Real Life versus the TV shows. I do watch these shows now and then and one thing that always ways tends to happen in the last 5 mins of every show is the 'Reluctant Confession'. If we get past the CSI interviewing the suspects (that particular moan is for another day) what amuses me is that when faced with the most tenuous of evidence in interview the suspect feels compelled to spill all the beans there and then, basically negating any kind of not guilty plea. In real life however they would probably be NFA'd before this interview occurred most like after Pre Charge Advice from the CPS!

Ok that may be a bit harsh on our lovely CPS, but let me tell you a story just to back it up a little. A shop on a High St was broken into, method of entry was smashed window to rear of shop, money taken from till, escape, job done. Yours truly turns up, (dashingly handsome, expensive suit and sunglasses) says something enigmatic, removes sunglasses and gets to work. I find some blood on the broken edges of the glass, photograph it, test it, swab it, say something profound, sunglasses back on and stare wistfully into the distance.

A full profile is found from the blood identifying our offender, turns out our offender is related to to the shop owner who can confirm that the offender has not set foot in the shop for weeks and the window was in tact when he did. So the Officer In Charge of the case presents this evidence to CPS, who turn around and say (with absolutely no scientific basis at all) No Further Action as Victim and offender are related their blood could be similar!!! It beggars belief really, a full profile has a discriminating factor of 1 in 1 Billion. Maybe they meant similar in colour.

3 comments:

Gargoyle said...

The way most carefully gathered evidence goes over here too! It can get very dissapointing, if you let it...

Gargoyle said...

By the way, I like watching CSI too, just to make fun of it. The best episode was the one with the arm sticking out of the concrete foundations of a house. The bad guy would have had to cut a hole in the formwork, pulled the arm through it and poured the cement over the body...

I don't think so!

Mr Mans Wife said...

Ahh, the sunglasses... you've been watching CSI Miami haven't you? With Horatio (sp?)

I have to confess, we love CSI in our house - the original mind you, with Gill Grissom and his crew. (I always suspected that CSI's doing interviews was a bit unrealistic though.) But we can't bear CSI NY or Miami. I don't even know where to start so I'm not even going to go there!